Long live Austrian economics

Kelly Evans's afternoon commentary & top market stories

VIEW IN BROWSER | SUBSCRIBE FRI, AUG 20, 2021 YOUR AFTERNOON NEWS UPDATE AND MARKET ACTION FROM CNBC AS OF FRI, AUG 20, 2021 • 11:16 ET DJIA 35069.31 +0.50% +175.19 S&P 500 4432.40 +0.60% +26.60 NASDAQ 14675.41 +0.92% +133.62   EDITOR'S NOTE For anyone (hello, FinTwit) watching the long, drawn-out debate between Austrian and Keynesian economics, it would have easily seemed that despite the brief ascent of post-crisis movements like the Tea Party, the Keynesians had won this battle for the "right" way to do macro years ago, and that was that.    Ah, but not so fast. The Keynesians might firmly hold the reins of the U.S. financial system--but the Austrians are busy working away on Bitcoin, crypto, and DeFi. Case in point: in Swan's brief announcement that it had hired podcaster Stephan Livera, the Bitcoin platform (really more of a savings app) proudly announced that not only does Livera  have millions of listeners, but he also has "extensive knowledge...about Austrian Economics."    I keep joking to my dad that he should become a crypto consultant on the side, given that he studied economics in college under Hans Sennholz, who himself had studied under one of the Austrian masters, Ludwig von Mises. I wonder if he saved his notes.    In any case, I point all of this out for two reasons. One, that it becomes a true face-off between two sharply different schools of economic thought, as for which approach can now create the most value. Before, it basically came down to Keynesians grow GDP, Austrians want to shrink it. Now, it's Keynesians can have their dollars, and Austrians will have their Bitcoin.    The whole point of Bitcoin is that it's supposed to be "hard money" that can't be deflated away. And it's a pretty intriguing notion. Who wasn't turned off by Bitcoin's volatility in its early days, especially after the huge run-up in 2017 followed by the crash? Didn't exactly feel like hard money back then. But now, post-pandemic, you think, well, my dollars certainly don't go as far as they used to (whether measured by real estate, stocks, commodities, etc.), but Bitcoin's purchasing power is still up appreciably.   Sometimes, watching the almost indistinguishable moves in Bitcoin and the Dow day-to-day, I think it's almost like they turned the Dow into money. Imagine if your dollars rose in value from when you first held them--your teenage job would have paid really well in that sense! Ironically, that would have meant that America's oldest families would be even wealthier (since their dollars started earlier) versus those who got rich more recently. But since we started in 2009, the reason why people say that Bitcoin could be a massive transfer of wealth is that it rewards those who held it earliest--a lot of whom were not 1%ers--as it keeps rising in value.    If it keeps rising in value, of course. The second point to make here is that this is also an experiment in whether Bitcoin can stay true to its "hard-money" roots. A lot of the other coins--like dogecoin--have already thrown this out the window, and can create more supply anytime, much like the U.S. Fed. The reason Bitcoin itself has so many hardcore aficionados, like Strike's Jack Mallers, is that it is programmed to have a fixed supply of 21 million coins, period.    It is for this reason I watch the whole stablecoin issue with great interest. There has been a massive printing of stablecoins this year, as Caitlin Long described on this excellent podcast with, yes, Stephan Livera. Much like bank system leverage created overly inflated asset values in 2007-09, are stablecoins artificially inflating the price of Bitcoin and other cryptos? Is all this consistent with Austrian principles?    The answers to these questions are way above my paygrade. But I'm just pleased to now have a real-time way to explore the real-world outcomes you get using an Austrian (if it stays that way) versus a Keynesian approach to money.    See you at 1 p.m!   Kelly Kelly Evans Twitter: @KellyCNBC Instagram: @realkellyevans KEY STORIES  Porn made OnlyFans a powerhouse. Now it's banning sexual content after pressure from banks OnlyFans said it will no longer allow "sexually explicit" content, starting Oct. 1. 'Jeopardy!' producer Mike Richards steps down as incoming host after controversial past comments Mike Richards has stepped down as the host of "Jeopardy!" Malaysia gets a new prime minister — the country's third in 3 years Malaysia's King Sultan Abdullah has named Ismail Sabri Yaakob as the country's new prime minister, the palace said in a Friday statement. Here's why the ultra-wealthy like Bill Gates and Thomas Petterfy are investing in U.S. farmland An estimated 30% of all farmland is owned by landlords who don't farm themselves, according to U.S. Department of Agriculture. Apple delays return to office until January as Covid cases surge Apple staff won't be returning to the office until January, amid fears over surging coronavirus cases. Topps SPAC merger with Mudrick Capital dies because MLB killed 70-year-old trading card deal Topps had been the trading card partner of Major League Baseball since 1952. Its SPAC merger with Mudrick Capital just blew up. Disney is developing an exoskeleton that could bring the Hulk to its theme parks With Project Exo, Disney's research and development team is trying to bring the company's biggest characters to life at its theme parks. Coinbase is buying $500 million in crypto and investing future profits into a crypto portfolio Coinbase will buy $500 million in crypto on its balance sheet and allocate 10% of its quarterly profits into a crypto assets portfolio. Foot Locker shares soar on huge earnings beat and on retailer's optimism for 2H Foot Locker crushed fiscal second-quarter earnings estimates and voiced optimism about the back half of the year. August is usually volatile, and the delta variant is making it worse The markets: It's August, but it's also Covid. Normal August trading flows are being greatly complicated by the delta variant.     IN CASE YOU MISSED IT Water shortages will affect more industries than just agriculture Will the delta variant derail the restaurant industry again? Here's what you should look for in luxury brand stocks   Unsubscribe Manage Newsletters Terms of Service Join the CNBC Panel Digital Products Feedback Privacy Policy   © 2021 CNBC LLC. All rights reserved. A property of NBCUniversal. 900 Sylvan Avenue, Englewood Cliffs, NJ 07632 Data is a real-time snapshot *Data is delayed at least 15 minutes. Global Business and Financial News, Stock Quotes and Market Data and Analysis. Data also provided by THOMSON REUTERS